Sunday, April 19, 2015
FAIRFIELD-SUISUN, CALIFORNIA
99 CENTS

Did expiring benefits drive down the jobless rate?

By
From page A8 | August 11, 2014 |

In January, I wrote a column questioning the morality of continuing to extend jobless payments to Americans looking for work.

It didn’t come from a coldhearted supposition that unemployed people don’t deserve benefits.

I was contemplating the results of a recent study by four distinguished economists, released through the National Bureau of Economic Research. The study concluded that “unemployment benefit extensions can account for most of the persistently high unemployment after the Great Recession.”

That may seem counterintuitive to people who argue that unemployment benefits create jobs by giving the unemployed money to spend. The bureau’s study found that in fact, these benefits are more likely to be a job killer.

Using a novel method of empirical modeling, the authors found that extensions of long-term unemployment benefits may have perpetuated unemployment in recent years and made the prospects of finding jobs even worse.

The economists argued that continuing to extend benefits forces businesses to raise wages to incentivize workers to take vacant jobs.

And with decreased profit margins, businesses create fewer positions.

It’s a logical conclusion and hardly one motivated by disdain for Americans searching for work.

The study was released at the peak of a heated congressional debate about extending long-term unemployment insurance yet again. Those on the left who supported the extensions accused Republicans, who did not, of being heartless.

But maybe Republicans were just being smart.

As Congress could not come to a resolution on benefits extensions, they expired at the end of 2013.

Since then, we have more economic data, much of it reinforcing the plainly logical conclusion of the bureau’s study: People are more likely to seek and secure jobs after the benefits run out.

In July, the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis looked at how the expiration of long-term unemployment benefits affected the unemployment rate in early 2014. The study concluded, as the bureau’s paper postulated, that it probably contributed to a reduction in the number of out-of-work Americans.

“Without extended UI benefits, these unemployed workers would have been more likely to be employed . . .  and on average 1.9 percent less likely to remain unemployed in the following period,” the Reserve Bank wrote.

Similarly, many analysts have pointed to North Carolina’s experience.

Long-term unemployment benefits ended in the Tar Heel State in July 2013, six months before benefits expired for other states. As The Wall Street Journal reported, “The jobless rate plummeted from 9.5 percent at the start of 2013 to 6.9 percent at the end, as 110,930 people left the labor force and overall employment rose by 13,414.”

The Obama administration has been touting this year’s steady uptick in jobs numbers, which topped 200,000 for the sixth month in a row in July. Of course, this is good news for all Americans, regardless of political stripe.

But it’s important for us to consider what might be contributing to this success. Like it or not, the expiration of long-term unemployment benefits probably played a part.

This recovery has been one of the longest and slowest on record.

July’s report from the Bureau of Labor Statistics shows that the real unemployment rate – which includes short-term discouraged and other marginally attached workers as well as those forced to work part time because they cannot find full-time employment – is 12.2 percent, or double the reported July rate.

But over the past year, long-term unemployment has dropped 25 percent, by about 1.1 million workers. It’s worth wondering why.

Of all the policy areas subject to partisan back-and-forth these days, perhaps this is one where conservatives have gotten the better part of the argument.

Cynthia M. Allen is a columnist for the Fort Worth Star-Telegram. Readers may send her email at [email protected].

Cynthia M. Allen

LEAVE A COMMENT

Discussion | 23 comments

The Daily Republic does not necessarily condone the comments here, nor does it review every post. Read our full policy

  • rlw895August 11, 2014 - 6:20 am

    No argument from me. Unemployment benefits have to stop at some point. There still needs to be a "social safety net," but unemployment benefits should be temporary.

    Reply | Report abusive comment
  • Tired-of-itAugust 11, 2014 - 7:05 am

    Rlw: So, since you believe everyone should get assistance so they won't die, is it your solution to remove people from unemployment and put them in the welfare system? Really? It seems you missed the point of the study.

    Reply | Report abusive comment
  • rlw895August 11, 2014 - 11:30 pm

    No, I don't think so. What point do you think I missed?

    Reply | Report abusive comment
  • Tired-of-itAugust 12, 2014 - 8:27 am

    The point that if people stop receiving unemployment they will return to work. Removing them from unemployment and giving them a "social safety net" still wouldn't encourage them to find work, which was the point of the study. Once again, you're too quick to give hard working people's money to those that won't work.

    Reply | Report abusive comment
  • Mr. PracticalAugust 12, 2014 - 8:41 am

    FUTA is conceptually a worthwhile program. Being able to keep a household going during periods of unemployment is a good thing. Here's the problems.... 1) No accountability that the beneficiary is making an effort to look for work. 2) FUTA is a Federally mandated program that the states administrate. The extended benefit period drained the state's account. But the Feds said, "no problem, you can borrow from us." Now California owes $11 billion. How do you propose we pay that back? 3) Employees have no skin in the game. FUTA is funded entirely by the employer. This should work like SSI and the cost split with the employee.

    Reply | Report abusive comment
  • rlw895August 17, 2014 - 3:05 pm

    TOI: No, I got that. But what you don't get is that someone who has worked and enjoyed the income is not likely to want to stay on public assistance if it is at the subsistence level. It's nothing like being on unemployment. I wouldn't worry about it being a disincentive to work, not like unemployment might be.

    Reply | Report abusive comment
  • Mr. PracticalAugust 17, 2014 - 3:39 pm

    rlw, it cuts both ways. The majority (and my hunch is a slight majority) do try to go back to work and look for work diligently. There are way too many that don't try at all until benefits are about to expire. There is another group that won't widen the net. They won't apply for or accept work below their previous pay, or not in their previous industry. Employees do not contribute towards the unemployment benefits. It is a tax on employers. If you're receiving benefits, your full-time job should be looking for work. If you receive an offer, even at at a low wage, you are obligated to accept that work. Anything less is abusing the system. There is no accountability to prove you're looking for work beyond checking a box on a mailing from EDD acknowledging that you did look for work. TOI is correct in the case of many people. Stopping the extended benefits will in fact get more people back to work. This is another example of this administration hurting economic recovery.

    Reply | Report abusive comment
  • rlw895August 17, 2014 - 5:29 pm

    Mr.P: We're talking nuance here. There was general agreement to extend unemployment benefits the first time, and less support each time thereafter. Maybe it went too long, but not much. In any event, it's within the range of error we should be able to accept.

    Reply | Report abusive comment
  • Mr. PracticalAugust 17, 2014 - 5:43 pm

    rlw, my point isn't regarding the benefit period. It's the lack of accountability. For every person that gets a check that didn't look for work that period, we could pay someone longer that is trying to better their situation but hasn't had any luck. It should also work like SSI. Employer matches the employee contribution.

    Reply | Report abusive comment
  • rlw895August 17, 2014 - 9:52 pm

    Mr.P: I'm good with that, but it would require greater government expense to implement and monitor. Case workers with reasonable case loads. Then we're back to bigger government. Will you agree to that?

    Reply | Report abusive comment
  • JagAugust 17, 2014 - 10:06 pm

    One more thing that could maybe done is extend unemployment according to the county, For example I remember once we started to recover San Francisco County was around 7% while Solano county the worst in the Bay Area was still up around 12%

    Reply | Report abusive comment
  • Mr. PracticalAugust 18, 2014 - 7:22 am

    rlw, since it's a state program (mandated by the feds and none of their business), I have less concern philosophically with growing government. That being said, California is bloated and has grown way to big, particularly with its regulatory agencies. I'm not sure if the administration of benefits is paid for from the taxes collected. If it is, than I doubt that reasonable accountability would require more cost. I'll crunch numbers tonight and see what it would take.

    Reply | Report abusive comment
  • rlw895August 18, 2014 - 8:19 am

    Mr.P: A lot can be done with technology. Maybe no one has tried yet.

    Reply | Report abusive comment
  • Mr. PracticalAugust 18, 2014 - 9:38 am

    rlw, absolutely. During the height of unemployment I was laid off after the company I worked for in NAPA was acquired by McAfee. They closed the two offices we had in California and consolidated to existing offices in Texas. It was extremely difficult to find work. It took me seven months. Here's how the unemployment process worked. After your claim is approved, you receive a debit card and all payments are applied to that account. That was a great idea, Rather than mailing physical checks. However, the notice they send each two weeks where you have to report whether or not you looked for work or found work, is still done by physical mail. They could certainly email that report with a link to an online form. I am sure there are a lot of other improvements that could be made through technology.

    Reply | Report abusive comment
  • BobAugust 11, 2014 - 6:49 am

    I agree, why work if they are being handed money. When ever I had to fall back on unemployment there was not enough to keep the family going, I'd look for work but I was over qualified for every job I applied for until construction picked up again. With plastic cards, direct deposit, the Feds have made it too easy, go back to standing in long lines and spending days getting your check then stand in lines to cash it at the next window, that might make people want to go back to work.

    Reply | Report abusive comment
  • JagAugust 11, 2014 - 9:00 am

    see sometimes being the party of NO is a good thing

    Reply | Report abusive comment
  • Mike KirchubelAugust 11, 2014 - 9:26 am

    The Tar-Heel State example she uses says that employment rose by 13,414 while those who left the workforce totaled 110,930. I would say that is not a good example of how this "cut benefits = increased employment" hypothesis works. I would call that "grabbing at straws."

    Reply | Report abusive comment
  • Mr. PracticalAugust 11, 2014 - 6:50 pm

    Mike, isn't that the same math the administration has been using when quoting the unemployment numbers? The point is, many people receiving the extended unemployment benefits are not looking for work until the benefits are about to expire. I got laid off at the height of unemployment. I applied for unemployment benefits for the first time in my life. I believed, that while I collected those benefits, that were paid for by a mandated tax on employers, that I had an obligation to make looking for a job my full-time job. I also had to widen the net of jobs I would accept. I stayed in touch with many of the people that were also laid off with me (btw.. the company moved to Texas - shocking!). Many did not bother looking for another job while receiving unemployment. There is no accountability to the program. You receive an application every two weeks. You check a box that says, "I looked for work" and the checks keep coming. When the extended benefits were extended the first time, Congress should have legislated accountability at the same time. It would have paid for itself. This column has complete credibility. The extended benefits also bankrupted the unemployment accounts in most states. California had to borrow $11 billion from the feds to pay those claims. Now, the state is proposing to pay the debt solely on another increase in the unemployment tax. That would put payroll taxes upwards to 20 percent. Good grief.

    Reply | Report abusive comment
  • JagAugust 11, 2014 - 7:25 pm

    Maybe you have kids or grandkids and you can not move but were you offered a job to go with them in Texas?

    Reply | Report abusive comment
  • Mr. PracticalAugust 11, 2014 - 7:47 pm

    Jag, the company was McAfee. They acquired a company in Napa that I was was working for that did vulnerability scanning and certification for ecommerce Websites. They had expanded operations of our unit in existing offices in Plano. I don't think they believed the move was a good idea, but they succumbed to shareholder pressure after one quarter of less than double digit revenue growth and decided to consolidate. Since they had already ramped up operations in Texas, they didn't need that many "experienced" people to make the move. They didn't offer anyone a job in Plano, rather they told us we could "reapply" for a job there. I was born and raised here and do have family here. We had no interest in moving anyway. One thing I will say for McAfee, is they offered a fair severance, brought in an outside vendor to help with updating resumes, interview training, etc... Myself and a few of the other top producers in sales were asked to stay on an additional two months to help until the transition was made and gave us additional severance for that. The 70 salespeople they had in Plano were primarily salespeople that were already in their inbound call centers for anti-virus product.. What we did was outbound sales and a completely different animal. The eight of us that were asked to stay, out sold the 70 salespeople they had in Plano by 4 times the final month. I sold to quite a few Websites you would recognize. One of the last was Hustler! Your credit card info is safe there!!!

    Reply | Report abusive comment
  • JagAugust 11, 2014 - 8:15 pm

    sorry to hear that, I do understand being raised here (Me To) I know McAfee very well we used Symantec until Microsoft included Fore Front in our Volume Licensing saving us over ten thousand a year. hopefully you are not commuting to San Jose every day where most of your work is, I am in SF and that is far enough,

    Reply | Report abusive comment
  • Mr. PracticalAugust 11, 2014 - 8:21 pm

    Jag, prior to that job, I was a small business owner for 30 years. I now work for a non-profit that advocates for small business in Sacramento and Washington DC. I'm in the field everyday talking to small business owners about how screwed up the government is. It never gets old!

    Reply | Report abusive comment
.

Solano News

Waiting game: Woman, toddler hope for kidney transplants

By Amy Maginnis-Honey | From Page: C1 | Gallery

 
Tiny twins call Heather House their 1st home

By Amy Maginnis-Honey | From Page: A1, 6 Comments | Gallery

Solano ranks last in Bay Area for health

By Ryan McCarthy | From Page: A1 | Gallery

 
SID to consider water rate hikes

By Kevin W. Green | From Page: A1

California water saving mandate shrinks cuts for some cities

By Staff and wire reports | From Page: A1

 
Who is the Bay Area’s most popular athlete?

By Brad Stanhope | From Page: A2

 
City announces Browns Valley Road closures

By Bill Hicks | From Page: A3

Healthier Living program begins mid-May

By Kevin W. Green | From Page: A3

 
Bachelor party turns into community event

By Susan Hiland | From Page: A3 | Gallery

Il Fiorello serves up chocolate desserts

By Susan Hiland | From Page: A3 | Gallery

 
When to throw in the towel on sickly plants

By Karen Metz | From Page: C4

Coping with seasonal allergies

By Emerita Brigino-Buenaventura, M.d | From Page: C4

 
Solano superhero back in school

By Kevin W. Green | From Page: A5

Church hosts health, wellness fair

By Susan Hiland | From Page: A5 | Gallery

 
Home, garden show offers something for everyone

By Bill Hicks | From Page: A6 | Gallery

Weather for Sunday, April 19, 2015

By Daily Republic staff | From Page: B6

 
2 nations at center of market drop

By Bud Stevenson | From Page: B7

Vanden robotics team ready to compete in world championships

By Bill Hicks | From Page: A7 | Gallery

 
Fairfield hotel gets major renovation

By Kevin W. Green | From Page: B7 | Gallery

 
Teen victim of Dixon shooting dies

By Bill Hicks | From Page: A7

Land use, design, project synergy key to growth

By Brian Miller and Karl Dumas | From Page: B7

 
Fairfield police log: April 17, 2015

By Glen Faison | From Page: A9

Suisun City police log: April 17, 2015

By Glen Faison | From Page: A9

 
Commissary-Exchange pairing gains steam

By Nick DeCicco | From Page: B10

Airmen with county ties complete training

By Nick DeCicco | From Page: B10

 
.

US / World

San Francisco marks anniversary of 1906 earthquake

By The Associated Press | From Page: A7

 
Time plus distance help some Oklahoma City victims move on

By The Associated Press | From Page: A7

Police: Officers kill man who charged at them near St. Louis

By The Associated Press | From Page: A10

 
Scarlett O’Hara outfit fetches $137,000 at auction

By The Associated Press | From Page: A10

Turin Shroud goes back on display for faithful and curious

By The Associated Press | From Page: A10

 
Caged puppies on car roof trigger dozens of 911 calls

By The Associated Press | From Page: A10

French replica of revolutionary frigate sets sail for Boston

By The Associated Press | From Page: A11

 
Islamic State blamed for Afghan suicide bombing killing 35

By The Associated Press | From Page: A12

.

Opinion

 
Justice not served

By Letter to the Editor | From Page: A8, 4 Comments

Clinton should spruce up a bit

By Letter to the Editor | From Page: A8, 1 Comment

 
Brown support of ag water ruffles feathers

By Dan Walters | From Page: A8

 
Sound off for April 19, 2015

By Daily Republic | From Page: A8

Talk about corruption

By Letter to the Editor | From Page: A8

 
.

Living

Community Calendar: April 19, 2015

By Susan Hiland | From Page: A2

 
Today in history: Sunday, April 19, 2015

By The Associated Press | From Page: A2

Is it possible for Methodists to agree to disagree on gay marriage?

By The Washington Post | From Page: C3 | Gallery

 
Vatican unexpectedly ends crackdown of US nun group

By The Associated Press | From Page: C3

Horoscopes: April 19, 2015

By Holiday Mathis | From Page: C4

 
Wife needs to decide if she can tolerate husband’s binge drinking

By Kathy Mitchell and Marcy Sugar | From Page: C4

.

Entertainment

PUBLISHERS WEEKLY BEST-SELLERS

By The Associated Press | From Page: C2

 
Anna Kendrick has book of essays coming out in 2016

By The Associated Press | From Page: C2

Phil Klay, Leslie Jamison among PEN award nominees

By The Associated Press | From Page: C2

 
.

Sports

Crawford, Heston lead Giants to win

By The Associated Press | From Page: B1

 
Curry scores 34, Warriors beat Pelicans 106-99 in Game 1

By The Associated Press | From Page: B1 | Gallery

Reddick’s 3-run homer sends A’s to 5-0 victory over Royals

By The Associated Press | From Page: B1

 
Cal defense shines for a change at scripted spring game

By The Associated Press | From Page: B1

 
Serena Williams gets a rare test from Giorgi but holds on

By The Associated Press | From Page: B2

Tom Watson: Next Masters might be his last

By The Associated Press | From Page: B2

 
Free agent center Wisniewski signs 1-year deal with Jaguars

By The Associated Press | From Page: B2

Pete Rose hired by Fox as special guest studio analyst

By The Associated Press | From Page: B2

 
Marcotte, Ryan win US cycling Criterium championships

By The Associated Press | From Page: B2

Independent league experiments with 3-ball walks

By The Associated Press | From Page: B2

 
Merritt maintains edge through 3 rounds at RBC Heritage

By The Associated Press | From Page: B2 | Gallery

Jones throws 2 TDs, wins challenge at Ohio State spring game

By The Associated Press | From Page: B2 | Gallery

 
As Spurs know, international players can impact NBA playoffs

By The Associated Press | From Page: B3 | Gallery

Rose scores 23, Bulls beat Bucks 103-91

By The Associated Press | From Page: B3

 
Harden has 24 points, Rockets beat Mavs 118-108 in Game 1

By The Associated Press | From Page: B3

Pierce leads Wizards past Raptors in OT in Game 1

By The Associated Press | From Page: B3 | Gallery

 
Hometown report: Little League baseball

By Daily Republic staff | From Page: B4

Hometown report: Youth track

By Daily Republic staff | From Page: B4

 
Kenseth content in car and not contemplating retirement

By The Associated Press | From Page: B4 | Gallery

Logano leads flag-to-flag to win Xfinity race at Bristol

By The Associated Press | From Page: B4 | Gallery

 
This date in sports history for April 19

By The Associated Press | From Page: B5

 
.

Business

Using a prepaid card? Avoid getting socked with fees

By The Washington Post | From Page: B7

 
Recalls this week: blowers, bike hooks, mattresses, toys

By The Associated Press | From Page: B8

This year’s fight for the tech industry: Patent trolls

By The Associated Press | From Page: B8

 
IMS: US prescription drug spending jumped 13 percent in 2014

By The Associated Press | From Page: B9

Fast-growing Asian aviation confronts safety challenges

By The Associated Press | From Page: B9 | Gallery

 
USDA veterinarian: Bird flu outbreak could be ‘devastating’

By The Associated Press | From Page: B12

 
.

Obituaries

Carole Anspach

By Nancy Green | From Page: A4

 
Frances Bayona Lozano

By Nancy Green | From Page: A4

Robert Larkin

By Nancy Green | From Page: A4

 
Barbara Medders

By Nancy Green | From Page: A4

Carrol “Carl” Gordon Parker

By Nancy Green | From Page: A4

 
John Thompson

By Nancy Green | From Page: A4

Allen Ellsworth Dolby Sr.

By Nancy Green | From Page: A4

 
Sterling Jenkins

By Nancy Green | From Page: A5

Dennis Burkhart von Ting

By Nancy Green | From Page: A5

 
.

Comics