Our view

Hagel should be confirmed

Few presidential nominations have been as widely telegraphed as Barack Obama’s nomination of former Nebraska GOP Sen. Chuck Hagel to be secretary of Defense.

The leisurely process had the advantage for the administration of getting an advance look at the likely opposition, mostly some of Hagel’s erstwhile Republican colleagues, whom, it became clear, have an uphill battle to derail his nomination. Indeed, senior Republicans may decide that it’s not worth the political capital to significantly attack his nomination.

Hagel is a decorated – two Purple Hearts – Vietnam veteran. He would be – and this is an important consideration with a certain strata of public opinion – the first Vietnam veteran and former enlisted man to head the Pentagon.

After leaving the Senate in 2009, Hagel, 66, taught at Georgetown University and headed a centrist think tank, post-Senate career choices that indicate he has been itching to get back into public life. In the Senate and afterward, he was close to Obama and importantly for the Pentagon post he has the trust and confidence of the president.

The potentially most difficult issue for his confirmation is the charge by Republicans and some Democrats that he is insufficiently pro-Israel. He has differed with the Israeli lobby on questions of sanctions but on the major issues he has largely voted in support of Israel.

Further, once in office, the major questions of Israeli policy, especially vis-a-vis Iran, will be the responsibility of the Secretary of State, not Hagel and the Pentagon.

Another rap against Hagel, particularly among Democrats, is intemperate remarks he made about the pending appointment of a gay ambassador. He has apologized and endorses the Pentagon policy of gays serving openly in the military. After 12 years it seems some sort of statute of limitations should apply.

Curiously, in the early reaction to his nomination, both positive and negative, there has been little discussion of the most important issue he will face: Guiding the American military through an era of ever-tighter budgets and the concomitant military downsizing.

Hagel also has this going for him: As a Vietnam vet and an Iraq war skeptic, he will be anything but impulsive about committing U.S. troops to opened-ended military ventures. And that is no bad thing.

Based on what we know so far — and his confirmation hearing is still to be held — he should be confirmed.

Scripps Howard News Service


Discussion | 1 comment

The Daily Republic does not necessarily condone the comments here, nor does it review every post. Please read our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy before commenting.

  • rlw895January 09, 2013 - 9:58 pm

    Generally a president's nominees SHOULD be confirmed unless something new is discovered about fitness to serve. I held the same view during the Robert Bork hearings as Supreme Court justice back during the Reagan administration, which is where this tit for tat silliness started. It's made it harder on presidents and nominees alike from both parties. Now, Bork WAS a poor choice to replace moderate Louis Powell, but the country elected Ronald Reagan president, and I felt he should get his choice. Bork didn't do himself many favors during the hearings—BIG ego. In the end, the Democratic Senate rejected the Bork nomination and Reagan nominated Anthony Kennedy instead, who won confirmation and still serves. I'm not sure I'm right though. The next big SCOTUS nomination battle was over Clarence Thomas. I again sided with the president, George H. W. Bush. Thomas got through, but I now wish he hadn't. So maybe the Senate was right about Bork too. But I can't see how Hagel is a similarly bad nominee, and I REALLY object to the Republican minority blocking any nomination by Obama without a major revelation.

    Reply | Report abusive comment
  • Recent Articles

  • Enter your email address to subscribe and receive notifications of new posts by email.

  • Special Publications »

    Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Service (updated 4/30/2015) and Privacy Policy (updated 4/7/2015).
    Copyright (c) 2016 McNaughton Newspapers, Inc., a family-owned local media company that proudly publishes the Daily Republic, Mountain Democrat, Davis Enterprise, Village Life and other community-driven publications.